To compare Stripe vs Shopify Payments results, keep input, format and settings fixed and change one variable. Shopify Payments may avoid extra transaction fees but has platform rules; off-platform Stripe is more flexible.
Why it matters
Changing several variables at once makes results unattributable.
Off-platform transaction fees count.
Step by step
- Confirm amount, card type, country and currency.
- Separate base rate, fixed fee, international surcharge and conversion.
- Model refunds/disputes separately; do not use only successful-transaction rates.
- Calculate effective rate from actual monthly volume, not just the headline 2.9%.
Common mistakes
- Treating 2.9% + $0.30 as the rate for every transaction.
- Ignoring international card/conversion surcharges.
- Assuming the fixed fee is returned after a refund.
- Ignoring dispute fees and chargeback ratios.
Checklist
- Amount, card type, issuer country and settlement currency are explicit.
- Base + fixed + international + conversion are separated.
- Refunds, disputes, subscriptions and invoices are modeled separately.
- Effective rate is based on real monthly volume.
- Compare PayPal/Shopify/Wise on the same transaction.
Key facts
- Off-platform transaction fees count.
- Shopify rules apply.
- Separate channels.
FAQ
How do I compare two Stripe vs Shopify Payments results?
To compare Stripe vs Shopify Payments results, keep input, format and settings fixed and change one variable. Shopify Payments may avoid extra transaction fees but has platform rules; off-platform Stripe is more flexible.
How long does it take?
Usually 1-3 minutes; for intermittent issues, run 30 seconds and retest elsewhere.
Is data uploaded?
Runs locally and does not upload video/audio; extensions may still read the page.
Source: Shopify